

This book introduced several characters who would re-appear in later books - the Shaggy Man, Button Bright, and one of my favorites, Polychrome, the daughter of the rainbow. I was never as fond of the Shaggy Man and Button Bright. Something about the Shaggy Man disturbed me - I think it might have been his beard - and Button Bright was a little too infantile. I grew fonder of both in later books.
I have a small John R. Neill drawing that pictures a tramp who, with a little imagination, could be the Shaggy Man before he got so shaggy! This could be a magazine editorial illustration, ca. 1920 or so. The caption reads: The farmers wife who out of pity gives a good meal to a tramp is acting more wisely than the functionary who compells the tramp to earn his meal by hard labor.

I remember reading an old Baum Bugle article that referred to this as the "most dangerous Oz book", due to the fact that Dorothy arrives in Oz after wandering off the farm with a strange man. Certainly not an example to set for children! Personally, I would think Aunt Em and Uncle Henry would keep a closer eye on her - she had already been swept away in a cyclone, blown off a ship at sea, and fallen down an earthquake. Clearly, she attracted trouble.
No comments:
Post a Comment